Lovingly created by Jean Pierce and Kris Newman, originally from California's NapaValley, GrottoBay is a truly unique island getaway.
Beneath fruit trees, native hardwoods and exotic tropical greenery, lies an extensive cave system with still-forming stalactites and stalagmites.
Within the Grotto are banana palms and avocado trees, and beyond it are three massive chambers, all safe for exploring.
Every visit receives personalized attention.
The Grotto At Grotto Bay
The Play Area at Grotto Bay
At GrottoBay, guests enjoy a restful, secluded retreat that is within easy access to the island's best restaurants and services.
You'll have full use of our very private beach -- no neighbors!
We have a regulation horseshoe pit all set up on the beach, and we can put up the net for beach volleyball. At any time, you can take a kayak and paddle out to one of several gorgeous uninhabited cays.
If you're visiting the first week of June, you'll be able to enjoy the exciting Long Island Regattawhich takes place literally off of Grotto Bay's own beach!